Heating Repair vs. Replacement: Making the Right Decision


During the winter season, your heating system keeps your family warm, even if the temperature is below freezing outside. However, just like other equipment or appliances in your home, problems will eventually occur, at times leaving you with no option but to repair or replace your unit.

Regrettably, it’s been difficult for most homeowners to determine whether they should just opt for a heating system repair or a total replacement. Clearly most people would likely opt to simply get their system repaired over and over again, since it’s less costly in the short run.

Although there’s nothing wrong with trying to keep your costs lower by choosing repairs, certain issues may be more serious than you think, making a replacement a much sounder decision in the long run.

In this blog, we’ll not only discuss the clear signs that indicate your heating system needs a replacement, but also why you just might want to consider a repair job.

First, let’s look at those signs that your heating system might need replacement.

Age of your heating system

The initial factor to mull over when choosing between repair and replacement is the age of your heating system. By and large, a well-maintained heating system can last for 15-20 years. Nevertheless, if your system is approaching the end of its expected lifetime and you’ve been encountering numerous problems with it, it may just be time to think about replacing it rather than constantly repairing it. Let’s face it, an outdated heating unit will continue to break down repeatedly and demand costly repairs, which will add up over time.

System performance

When you go to the thermostat to adjust the indoor temperature, you ought to be able to count on your heating system to react properly. If the system isn’t generating heated air as it should, it may well be time to replace it. Problems including erratic heating, cold spots in parts of your house and unwarranted or unfamiliar noises might also point to a “must” replacement.

Frequent repairs

Hypothetically, there’s nothing amiss with simply getting your heating system repaired, even if it’s repeatedly. This is, not surprisingly, provided trained technicians do it, and there are existing spare parts. Still, doing so can cost an abundant amount of time and money.

Of course, maintenance visits and subsequent repairs are okay. However, if it comes to the point that you’re experiencing three, four, five or more visits a year, then you have to start clearly thinking about how you’re spending your money.

If this is the case, maybe it’s simply better to spend your money on a new, reliable heating system than spending it on getting your old one repaired.

Energy efficiency

It’s obvious. The ever-changing circumstances of heating technology and energy efficiency have altered the notion of a conventional heating system. Even an older system that’s had few issues is never going to be as efficient as a new model. Older systems are going to battle just to keep close with the mandates of today’s energy standards. Brand-new, more efficient systems not only guarantee long-term cost savings over time but also contribute to a greener, more sustainable home.

Environmental impact

In today’s environmentally conscious world, it’s important to take into account the environmental impact of your decision. It’s no secret. Older heating systems are less environmentally friendly as they discharge added pollution and greenhouse gases into the atmosphere. By replacing your outdated heating system with the latest, more energy-efficient model, you not only save money, but you also reduce your carbon footprint.

 

Greater home heating costs

As mentioned, the reduction in the efficiency of your heating system will boost your heating bills. And this is chiefly thanks to the rise in fuel consumption when employed in a less efficient system. So, over and beyond your usual energy bill with a more efficient system, you’ll also need to spend more to purchase fuel than you’d normally require.

 

Although a few repairs can improve your system’s efficiency, it wouldn’t make a massive difference. So, the next best thing you can do is find a new one that is guaranteed to lower your heating costs.

 

Cost implications

Another critical issue is the cost implications of both options. Usually, repairing your present heating system will be less costly upfront than replacing it. However, as mentioned, if your heating system is old and often breaks down, the cost of repairs will add up over time. On the other hand, although replacement will demand a higher initial investment, it will save you money in the long run due to better efficiency and less breakdowns.

 

Hint: For those who like to keep an eye on general guidelines, the $5,000 rule is an industry accepted standard for determining whether to repair or replace your heating system. Multiply the age of your equipment by its estimated repair cost. If the outcome is under $5,000, you should probably repair it.

 

So, is it worth repairing a heating system rather than replacing it?

As you’ll discover, when asking, “Should you repair or replace your heating system,” the answer is often “Go for the repairs.” However, if your heating system is less than 12 years old and has broken down for just the first time, you may actually want to think about a repair.

 

A skilled heating system repair technician from AC&R Services can visit your home and determine the source of your problems. In many instances, crews can swiftly perform repairs for issues triggered by:

  • Old or clogged filters
  • Dirt in the system’s ductwork
  • Failing starting mechanisms
  • Failures in the heat exchanger
  • Blower component problems
  • Issues with the limit switch

 

Our crews can also take a look at the thermostat to see if it needs adjusting. We’ll also examine your circuit breaker to see if the problem originated there. All we ask is you allow us to discuss your options before you make a decision, so you can make the choice that fits your needs.

 

Concluding thoughts

If you’re experiencing heating system issues, it may be time to consider replacing it. . . or perhaps a repair will fix the problem.

 

Contact us at AC&R Services to schedule a consultation and determine the best course of action for your heating system. Our experienced technicians will provide expert advice and quality services to keep your home warm and cozy. Don’t let a malfunctioning heating system disrupt your comfort. Make the right decision for your heating system now.